Since you never tell use what toppings you get on it I'm just going to pretend that you are a cheese and pepperoni guy. That would make you normal like me. (I can pretend you are normal if I want)
Maybe he will IF you can guess his preferred pizza topping in a 3-guesses-fairy-tale-sort-of-Rumplestiltskin-way.
'Course to be true to the story you'd need somehow overhear him talking about his favourite topping and be prepared with that knowledge should he ever kidnap your first born and challenge you.