Would you rather...

From: ANT_THOMAS23 May 2013 16:38
To: Ken (SHIELDSIT) 24 of 104
It does matter if you have guns or not.

Yes, if someone wants to kill someone they will probably manage it with or without guns being easily available but I still think someone has a better chance of surviving a knife attack than a gun attack.

One of the two people involved in the incident apparently had a gun. So obviously if you want to get hold of one over here it is possible, as has been mentioned many times before.

I just won't ever think legal gun ownership like in the US is ever going to be a good idea. The thought that people like those would have easier access to firearms is frightening to me. More crazy people with better access to guns is never a good state of affairs.

Whilst gun ownership might act as a deterrent I honestly believe it also results in people living in constant fear.

Then you look at the aspect of kids accidentally shooting each other. There's definitely been a number of stories like that in the news lately. What's all that about?
From: Ken (SHIELDSIT)23 May 2013 16:50
To: ANT_THOMAS 25 of 104
That's all about gun owners who don't take responsibility and keep their gun locked or someplace a child can't get it.

I don't live in constant fear. I like to pretend that the mere site of me puts other people in fear. It makes me feel powerful.
From: ANT_THOMAS23 May 2013 16:56
To: Ken (SHIELDSIT) 26 of 104
And there's plenty of people who are totally irresponsible so not letting them near guns legally is a good thing.

If not being able to own guns legally means the irresponsible parents can't buy them and it also means it's more difficult for the crazy people to buy them I'm more than happy to be totally unarmed.

I honestly believe that if we could legally own guns over here then last night someone else would have been killed in the aftermath with the likes of the EDL making their presence known.
From: Ken (SHIELDSIT)23 May 2013 17:02
To: ANT_THOMAS 27 of 104
Well there's another side to that.  If you don't allow people to legally own guns you are only addressing the people who follow the law.  Now you have an unarmed population who can't protect themselves from the people who do have guns. The people who have no intention to follow the laws. Removing every gun from the planet is impossible.  And now we are able to print them on a 3D printer, it's going to get real ugly.
From: ANT_THOMAS23 May 2013 17:07
To: Ken (SHIELDSIT) 28 of 104
It would be much uglier if everyone had guns.
From: ANT_THOMAS23 May 2013 17:08
To: Ken (SHIELDSIT) 29 of 104
It may be a view which you can't grasp but I am more than happy to be part of the unarmed population.
From: Ken (SHIELDSIT)23 May 2013 17:11
To: ANT_THOMAS 30 of 104
No, you're right I can't, because I've been around them since birth.  So it's just something we have.  If you're taught right from an early age there isn't anything to be afraid of and you know to respect it.

I kinda wish nobody knew anything about guns but it's too late for that.
From: koswix23 May 2013 17:25
To: Ken (SHIELDSIT) 31 of 104
>>And now we are able to print them on a 3D printer, it's going to get real ugly.

:'D you don't actually believe that shit, do you?

From: Ken (SHIELDSIT)23 May 2013 17:33
To: koswix 32 of 104
Believe what? That you can print a gun? If that's what you're asking me then the answer is yes. And if you don't then you should visit your favorite search engine.
From: Drew (X3N0PH0N)23 May 2013 17:40
To: Ken (SHIELDSIT) 33 of 104
As you say, if someone wants to kill someone, a great many things can be used as weapons. But guns are only weapons, they have no other purpose. Except for a very few which are designed for and only really useful for target shooting, they're designed for the sole purpose of hurting/killing other creatures. And in the vast majority of cases they're designed with humans in mind.

What does it say about your (people in such a country, not you specifically) attitude to life and your fellow humans that you feel the need to carry a weapon around? That you place that much of a premium on your safety, regardless of the cost to that of others.

It seems to me a very self-centred/selfish thing to do and bespeaks an uncivilised society, really.

It's not really, for me at least, about the guns. It's about the culture that allowing people to walk around armed fosters. An attitude to violence and human life that I just don't agree with and couldn't live with. And this is borne out by statistics since while your rate of homicides with firearms is obviously higher than ours (3.21 per 100k as opposed to 0.07 on our end) your non-firearm homicide rate is higher too (1.54 compared to 0.99).
From: Drew (X3N0PH0N)23 May 2013 17:43
To: Ken (SHIELDSIT) 34 of 104
You realise that it's a very shit gun? And that the printer required to print a working gun would cost tens of thousands of pounds? At this point, you may as well just buy a gun.

And while sure this stuff is going to eventually get better and cheaper to the point where most homes will have a 3D printer, you still won't be able to print ammo*. And we don't sell ammo here, so no problem.

(*until we get to like Diamond Age nano-printers, like)


From: koswix23 May 2013 17:59
To: Ken (SHIELDSIT) 35 of 104
I'm well aware of the shitty little plastic tube with a nail in the end. It's hardly a gun, though. 
From: Ken (SHIELDSIT)23 May 2013 18:00
To: koswix 36 of 104
So you don't think that will improve?
From: koswix23 May 2013 18:07
To: Drew (X3N0PH0N) 37 of 104
>>(*until we get to like Diamond Age nano-printers, like)

I had a lovely chat with one of the top bio-engineers from NASA a few weeks back. She was telling me about the replicators they're working on for the Mars mission (which she reckons will be GO GO GO as soon as the Chinese start making any realy progress in space (by which time the USA will have no money left anyway :'D )).

Anyway, they sound really cool. She's designing bacteria things that can a) self replicate and b) turn the Martian soil into bricks which are then assembled into buildings by robots. She's also working on a bio replicator that can build pretty much any organic organism (bacteria, vacine, food etc.) from a selection of raw ingredients and some instructions - crucially instructions that can be uploaded from Earth, so if the astronauts on mars suddenly get ill and need a vacine we can send it to them :D

Seemingly NASA's Mars plan is to have a base built and ready by the time the astronauts get there. I kept thinking she must be bullshitting me, but she seemed totally serious (and extremely knowledgeable)  about the whole thing.

From: koswix23 May 2013 18:08
To: Ken (SHIELDSIT) 38 of 104
Not until we can print materials with the same precision and strength of current manufacturing methods - and that is likely a /loong/ way off. And when that happens a 3D printed gun will be the least of our worries.
From: Ken (SHIELDSIT)23 May 2013 18:10
To: Drew (X3N0PH0N) 39 of 104
I didn't say it was a great gun but it shoots a projectile. Sure it will get better. And I'm sure they will come up with something for ammunition.
From: Ken (SHIELDSIT)23 May 2013 18:11
To: koswix 40 of 104
How long is a looong way off?  We are printing house foundations and a bunch of other shit already.  NASA is going to print food. I'd say 5 years max and they will have a pretty good printed gun.
From: Drew (X3N0PH0N)23 May 2013 18:12
To: koswix 41 of 104
I love that stuff :|
From: Drew (X3N0PH0N)23 May 2013 18:15
To: Ken (SHIELDSIT) 42 of 104
Taking this carrying around weapons thing to extremes. Say you had a barbecue and I was invited (as I'd better fucking be) and at the barbecue I carried around... a glaive, would that be ok? Or an RPG launcher? Or a hand grenade? I mean at what point does it become unacceptable to you?
From: Ken (SHIELDSIT)23 May 2013 18:20
To: Drew (X3N0PH0N) 43 of 104
A glaive might be cool! It depends how big it is. If you had a knife like Rambo I wouldn't think much about it, but if you carried a sword around I'd think you were a little fucked in the head.

The other things I wouldn't think were acceptable.  The items you listed are only used for military purposes, although I think some things like that are legal to own. I know you can own a tank as long as it can't fire. I have a friend who has a pretty good arsenal of mortar rounds too. Although I don't think you're allowed to have them.