ja ja

From: JonCooper 3 Jan 2007 10:21
To: Radio 29 of 36
I don't know about pain etc, but I assume you know what you're there for and what the injection is all about

it seems a bit barbaric to me to do something to someone and basically say "this'll kill you, in a while, won't be long now, ect"
From: Radio 3 Jan 2007 10:48
To: JonCooper 30 of 36

That's assuming that when you say it takes half an hour, they're conscious for all that time.
Isn't it just as bad as the walk to the noose though, or even sitting in the cell for days/weeks beforehand - knowing that you're to be put to death, but having to wait for the prearranged time?

From: Rowan 3 Jan 2007 15:40
To: Radio 31 of 36

It's a divided issue.

 

Opponents of lethal injection reckon that the chemical used to knock you out is actually only very short acting (which is why you're not allowed to use it for surgery, or for putting animals down), whilst the paralytic effects of the other drugs are not. So, basically, you get knocked out for a minute or two, wake up in paralysis and have to endure 30 mins of excruciating pain as you die.

 

Proponents disagree.

From: Mouse 3 Jan 2007 16:09
To: Rowan 32 of 36
Well why don't they use the same chemicals to knock you out wot they use for surgery and that?
EDITED: 3 Jan 2007 16:13 by MOUSE
From: Rowan 3 Jan 2007 16:56
To: Mouse 33 of 36
I'm not reet sure. Perhaps it's something to do with how they'd react with the kill-you chemicals, or perhaps it's expense. Opponents to the injection suggest an alternative, I think, but proponents are following an "if it ain't broke don't fix it" path.
From: Mouse 3 Jan 2007 17:10
To: Rowan 34 of 36
Aye, don't want em having a bad reaction and coming out in a rash or summink (nod)
From: JonCooper 3 Jan 2007 18:12
To: Radio 35 of 36
I dunno, I was thinking they were awake, more so since Rowans posts above
From: Manthorp 4 Jan 2007 19:49
To: ALL36 of 36
I'm wazzed and in parts exotic, but if either of u've got the inclination, there's a French revolutionary philosopher who did some pretty extreme experiments in which he grabbed guillotine victims from the Tumbrel and then roared questions in their ear. There seems to be some kind of confirmation of continuing conscioussness. Which is nice. sorta.