What about the best forum created project award?
Thinking about a certain summer cd that two members created cough cough :o)
Or the Fozza of the Dead and his Zombie Thread award for dragging up old threads?
(Admittedly, this one was marked as sticky, so I've unstickied it now, so thanks for that. And, um, I'm not sure I'll be volunteering to run the awards this year, what with the good chance of insanity around New Year, but I'll bear it in mind)