Have you got an old/another PC tucked away somewhere, as in try powering it with your BeQuiet PSU or try powering your current PC from the other PSU? The BeQuiet does look as though it has all sorts of fancy dohickeys and magic electric juju inside.
Do you have a hard drive (not solid state) you can use as a load i.e. plug in directly? I think these need 12V to spin up which would show whether it's supplying enough.
Edit: OK, I see you've moved on beyond this. Serves me right for taking a break to watch the telly before clicking on post.
EDITED: 21 Jul 2015 22:04 by WILLIAMA